TheStraightPipes gives the 2025 Cybertruck a solidly positive 76/100 OctaneScore, praising its exceptional performance with 600 hp and 0-60 in ~4 seconds, impressive livability features like the 6-foot bed with electrical plugs and automatic tonneau cover, and genuinely cool design that faithfully executes the polarizing stainless steel aesthetic. However, the steer-by-wire system creates unusual steering characteristics that take adjustment, the tiny rearview mirror lacks digital options, and at $137,900 CAD it's surprisingly expensive with slower 250 kW charging compared to some competitors' 350 kW. The Cybertruck is best suited for buyers who prioritize distinctive design and cutting-edge tech over convention, and who can afford the premium price tag.

Edmunds gave the 2026 Tesla Cybertruck Dual-Motor a negative review with a score of 36/100, citing serious reliability and technology concerns that overshadow some strong capabilities. The truck excels in economy with 334 miles of range per charge and demonstrates solid performance, accelerating 0-60 mph in 4 seconds and stopping from 60-0 mph in 126 feet, while offering a comfortable and intuitive driving experience once adapted. However, the vehicle experienced critical steering failures twice during testing that required system resets and left it immobilized, threw multiple powertrain error messages, and suffers from significant blind spots and visibility issues that Edmunds identified as the most difficult aspect of driving it. The Cybertruck is only for early adopters willing to accept substantial reliability risks in exchange for impressive acceleration and range.

Auto Buyers Guide gives the 2024 Tesla Cybertruck a mixed rating of 59/100, praising its exceptional value (qualifying for federal tax credits under $80,000), impressive performance (845 horsepower in the Cyberbeast variant with "bonkers fast" acceleration), and cabin technology including access to Tesla's supercharging network and a rear-seat touchscreen for passengers. However, the review highlights significant concerns around reliability (33/100) due to noise transmission from unibody construction and durability questions about soft-touch materials, plus economy drawbacks including one of the smaller batteries available and an unconfirmed 340-mile range. The divisive angular design and visible panel ripples also present maintenance challenges despite easier stainless steel upkeep. This truck appeals to early-adopter tech enthusiasts and performance-focused buyers willing to overlook reliability concerns and range limitations, rather than traditional truck owners prioritizing practicality.

Doug DeMuro gives the 2024 Tesla Cybertruck a moderately positive review with a score of 62/100, praising its revolutionary design and exceptional performance. The truck excels in cabin technology (94/100)—featuring household outlets in the bed, a steer-by-wire system requiring only half a steering wheel turn, and unique touches like an angular pixelated dog in dog mode—while its performance (100/100) and efficiency (100/100) are genuinely impressive, with the Beast variant hitting 0-60 in the 2-second range and the cover adding 10% to range. However, DeMuro highlights significant drawbacks: the price tag of $88,200-$102,000 represents a major departure from Tesla's original 2019 announcement, and early reliability concerns include premature stainless steel wear and a recall for defective wheel covers. The Cybertruck is best suited for early adopters and Tesla enthusiasts willing to pay premium prices for polarizing design and cutting-edge technology rather than practical truck ownership.

Edmunds gave the 2024 Tesla Cybertruck a perfect 100/100 score, highlighting exceptional real-world efficiency that exceeded expectations—the dual motor Foundation Series delivered 334 miles of range in testing, surpassing Tesla's 318-mile estimate and marking the first Tesla to meet or exceed its range claim. The vehicle also generates extraordinary public attention, with Edmunds describing it as "bananas" and a "legit celebrity on the road" that draws crowds of admirers. With no negative dimensions identified in this review, the Cybertruck appeals to buyers seeking cutting-edge EV technology, impressive range performance, and a vehicle that commands attention wherever it goes.

Redline Reviews gave the 2024 Tesla Cybertruck a solidly positive 72/100 OctaneScore, expressing excitement about the vehicle's arrival after a five-year wait. The truck excels in performance (100/100)—with the dual-motor Foundation Series delivering 600 horsepower and 0-60 in under 6.5 seconds—and cabin technology (90/100), featuring powered door controls, premium electronic window controls, and up to 9.6 KW of power outlets. The design earns 88/100 praise for its otherworldly Tron-inspired stainless steel exoskeleton, though the single-color limitation and need for wrapping to change colors is a drawback. The critical caveat is value (0/100 negative): the Foundation Series costs well over $100,000—far from the original $40,000 promise—and new reservations are sold out until 2027. This Cybertruck is for early adopters and performance enthusiasts willing to pay premium prices for cutting-edge technology and distinctive design.

Throttle House's review of the 2024 Tesla Cybertruck Cyberbeast is decidedly negative (38/100), with 32 negative highlights outweighing 28 positive ones. The vehicle excels in raw performance—delivering 845 horsepower, 0-60 mph in 2.68 seconds, and an industry-leading sound system—but stumbles significantly in livability, with poor visibility, buffeting during acceleration, and an unreliable touchscreen-only interface that forces drivers to look right constantly. More troubling are the value proposition (0/100), reliability concerns about creaks and squeaks despite its $100,000+ price, and Throttle House's assessment that it "overpromised and underdelivered" on range and towing capacity compared to Elon Musk's claims. The Cybertruck is best suited for early adopters and Tesla enthusiasts willing to tolerate unconventional design and usability trade-offs for cutting-edge acceleration and technology.