Critics Consensus
A thrilling but contradictory machine: the Taycan delivers genuine supercar performance and cutting-edge tech that reviewers universally celebrate, yet its astronomical price, range limitations, and impracticality for real-world use create a widening gap between what it promises and what wealthy buyers can actually do with it.
7 Reviews
Doug DeMuro gives the 2025 Porsche Taycan GTS Sport Turismo a strong 74/100 rating, praising its exceptional design refinements, impressive performance with 596 hp and 0-60 in 3.1 seconds, and practical improvements like the wagon body style's expanded cargo area and air suspension that raises the car for easier entry. The economy scores perfectly at 100/100 thanks to an improved battery system with faster charging and maintained range, while the active ride suspension dramatically reduces body roll in real-world driving. The main drawback is the premium price tag, and some cabin tech feels half-baked—like the climate controls that require screen menus instead of physical adjusters despite other clever touches like the auto-opening charge port. This is the EV to buy if you want a genuinely cool, practical sports car that feels like a real Porsche rather than just an electric appliance.
▶ Watch Review ↗TheStraightPipes gave the 2025 Porsche Taycan Turbo GT a strong 80/100 score, highlighting its exceptional performance and engineering as a standout sedan. The review emphasizes the car's 1,190 horsepower, sub-2-second 0-60 acceleration, and world-class suspension that delivers both a "Magic Carpet Ride" and track-capable dynamics with Attack Mode—areas where reliability and driving technology scored perfectly at 100/100. The main drawbacks are its steep pricing (starting at $270,000 CAD with the test vehicle at $281,500, more expensive than a Tesla Model S Plaid), modest real-world range of 605 km, and some infotainment control quirks, though the reviewer praised its superior build quality. The Taycan Turbo GT is built for performance enthusiasts and luxury buyers willing to pay premium prices for one of the fastest production sedans available.
▶ Watch Review ↗Redline Reviews gives the 2025 Porsche Taycan Turbo GT a strongly positive 76/100 OctaneScore, praising it as the ultimate electric track weapon with 1,019 horsepower in attack mode and calling it "absolutely otherworldly." The sedan excels in performance (96/100), design (90/100), and cabin technology (100/100), featuring an aggressive front fascia with integrated winglets and a customizable 16.8-inch display, while weighing 1,776 pounds less than the regular Turbo S. However, significant compromises exist for daily driving: the removed power-operated rear liftgate requires manual closing, cargo space is severely limited, and the $230,000+ starting price is steep even for Porsche. This is a purpose-built machine for enthusiasts prioritizing track performance and exclusivity over practicality.
▶ Watch Review ↗SavageGeese gave the 2024 Porsche Taycan Turbo GT a positive 63/100 rating, praising it as a genuinely usable electric performance car with exceptional technology and range. The standout strengths are its innovative Porsche Active Ride suspension system with individual wheel control, efficiency improvements that deliver mid-300 mile real-world range, and track performance—achieving a sub-seven-minute Nürburgring lap at 1,100 horsepower despite weighing 5,000 pounds. However, the vehicle's astronomical $230,000 starting price and brake-by-wire system (rather than a traditional brake pedal) represent significant drawbacks that temper enthusiasm. The Taycan Turbo GT is built for wealthy enthusiasts seeking a track-capable EV with daily usability and cutting-edge suspension technology, though not for buyers sensitive to premium pricing.
▶ Watch Review ↗Edmunds gives the 2024 Porsche Taycan Turbo GT a mixed but encouraging review (53/100), praising Porsche's execution of an electric performance car that maintains the brand's DNA. The standout strengths are its extreme performance credentials—1,092 horsepower (most powerful production Porsche ever) and 0-60 in 2.2 seconds—plus thoughtful design touches like the carbon fiber rear wing and aerodynamic diffuser on the Weissach Edition, and innovative cabin tech such as paddle shifters that activate a 10-second "attack mode." The significant drawbacks are its impracticality for daily use: the Weissach Edition ditches rear seats entirely and lacks available EV range figures, while Edmunds notes you'd need a tow truck with fast chargers to actually use it on a track day due to battery limitations. This ultra-exclusive hypercar is built for collectors and track enthusiasts who prioritize raw power and exclusivity over real-world usability.
▶ Watch Review ↗Redline Reviews gives the 2025 Porsche Taycan Turbo S Cross Turismo a strongly positive 82/100 rating, praising its exceptional performance and efficiency—0-60 in 2.4 seconds with 938 horsepower on launch control, plus 391 miles of EPA-estimated range and 320 kW DC charging capability. The cabin tech (96/100) and design (89/100) also impress, with the reviewer highlighting the stunning 16.8-inch curved OLED display, adaptive HD Matrix headlights, and the elegant new "Province" lavender color. However, the value proposition suffers significantly (20/100), with costly options like the $5,000 panoramic sunroof frost feature, $1,500 quad-zone climate control, and $1,800 leather rear seat upgrades that quickly compound the already premium price tag. This Cross Turismo is built for buyers seeking a family-practical, sports-car-capable EV who prioritize performance and tech over affordability.
▶ Watch Review ↗Edmunds gave the 2025 Porsche Taycan 4S a perfect 100/100 score, with universally positive impressions across all tested areas. The standout strengths are efficiency and range—the refreshed model achieved 343 highway miles on a single charge while consuming well under 30 kWh per 100 miles, and its maximum charging speed jumped to 332 kilowatts from the previous generation's 270 kilowatts. The two-speed transmission also contributes to strong highway efficiency for an EV, and climate control keeps the cabin comfortable in typical conditions. With no notable negatives identified in this review, the Taycan 4S is ideal for buyers prioritizing long-range capability, quick charging infrastructure, and efficient daily driving in a performance-oriented package.
▶ Watch Review ↗