SavageGeese gives the 2025 Nissan Kicks a positive 79/100 rating, praising it as a straightforward, enjoyable vehicle with excellent cabin technology and driving features. The standout strengths include wireless Android Auto and Apple CarPlay that connect without lag, an improved all-wheel drive system with new rear suspension, and a refreshed 2.0L engine delivering 20 more horsepower than before, all supported by intuitive steering wheel controls and responsive Bridgestone tires. The main concerns are reliability issues—SavageGeese uncovered multiple CVT bugs and calibration problems despite Nissan's claimed improvements—plus mixed feelings on its quirky shoe-inspired styling and the $1,500 AWD upcharge that reduces cargo space by 2-4 cubic feet. This Kicks suits buyers who value simplicity, practicality, and hassle-free tech over performance or cutting-edge design, as long as they're comfortable with Nissan's ongoing CVT track record.

Auto Buyers Guide gives the 2025 Nissan Kicks a strongly positive review with an OctaneScore of 86/100, praising its exceptional value (scoring a perfect 100/100), fuel economy, and driving technology features like standard adaptive cruise control with radar sensors. The redesigned Kicks impresses with increased interior space, improved 141-horsepower performance, and a refreshed exterior design that stands out from previous generations, though the rear design's shiny black plastic bar remains polarizing. The main compromise areas are livability and design scores in the mid-60s, reflecting the lack of power seat adjustments and less engaging rear suspension in front-wheel-drive models. The Kicks is ideal for budget-conscious buyers seeking a fuel-efficient, well-equipped subcompact SUV who can overlook some interior conveniences for strong value and modern safety tech.

Redline Reviews gave the 2025 Nissan Kicks SR AWD a highly positive 93/100 OctaneScore, praising its strong performance and economy, with the new 2-liter engine delivering a meaningful 141 horsepower upgrade and delivering an impressive 31 MPG combined, while the cabin tech and livability scores of 86/100 and 85/100 respectively highlight standout features like dual 12.3-inch displays, a 360-degree camera system (a segment first), and significantly more cargo space than before. The design scores a solid 75/100, though the gloss black grille is noted as prone to showing scratches and chips despite its aggressive appearance. The 2025 Kicks is an excellent fit for budget-conscious first-time buyers and those seeking an entry-level SUV that delivers impressive value and features compared to competitors like the Kona and Trax.

The 2025 Nissan Kicks earns a positive 70/100 OctaneScore, with standout achievements in design and driving technology—featuring a modern concept car-inspired exterior with full LED lighting, newly available all-wheel drive, and adaptive cruise control with parking sensors. The cabin tech also impresses with a two-screen setup on higher trims and wireless charging, while the refreshed dimensions provide notably more ground clearance and cargo space than before. However, performance is a significant weakness, as the added 300-500 lbs of curb weight counteracts the new 2.0L engine's power gains, resulting in expected performance lower than the outgoing model. The Kicks is best suited for budget-conscious buyers prioritizing practicality, modern features, and all-weather capability over driving dynamics, particularly those who can secure one under $25,000.

Redline Reviews gave the 2025 Nissan Kicks SR an overwhelmingly positive assessment with a 96/100 OctaneScore, praising its bold new design, advanced cabin technology, and strong value proposition. The reviewer highlighted the sportier styling with an enlarged grille and attractive 19-inch wheels, the dual 12.3-inch displays with Nissan's latest infotainment system, and the impressive pricing starting just under $25,000 despite feeling like a more expensive vehicle. The main drawback is limited rear-seat adjustability, as the seats don't recline or move forward and backward, though the overall size has grown with a 2.5-inch longer body and 2-inch longer wheelbase. The 2025 Kicks is ideal for budget-conscious buyers seeking modern technology, improved performance (now with AWD and 141 horsepower), and attractive styling without sacrificing value.

Auto Buyers Guide gave the 2025 Nissan Kicks a positive review with a score of 68/100, praising its redesigned livability with zero gravity seats, increased ground clearance, and the long-requested addition of all-wheel drive. The vehicle excels in design with its boxier, more premium appearance and cabin tech on higher trims, which feature impressive 12.3-inch twin screens and Bose audio systems, though base models lack Apple CarPlay and Android Auto. However, the Kicks stumbles significantly on performance—despite a new 2.0L engine with 141 horsepower, the vehicle weighs up to 500 lbs more than before, likely making it slower than its predecessor, and pricing is expected to push toward $25,000 despite being positioned as an affordable option. The 2025 Kicks is best suited for budget-conscious buyers who prioritize comfort, style, and practicality over driving dynamics.

SavageGeese gave the 2026 Nissan Kicks a mixed 45.8/100 rating, finding compelling strengths in design and value but significant weaknesses elsewhere. The reviewer praised the second-generation's larger, more rigid construction and "really well executed" interior that looks nicer than the HRV or Corolla Cross, plus an attractive $24,000-$25,000 starting price—though depreciation trails competitors. However, the Kicks stumbles badly on comfort and performance: the CVT is described as "one of the most uninspiring drivetrains," ride quality loses to rivals, rear legroom is cramped for adults over six feet, and the 139 hp engine struggles with 0-60 times in the nines. The Kicks makes sense for budget-conscious buyers prioritizing design and initial affordability over refinement and long-term value retention.