The 2026 BMW i5 M60 earns a mixed 50/100 score from Edmunds, though the reviewer clearly respects its strengths as a luxury electric sedan. The i5 excels in performance and efficiency, delivering nearly 600 horsepower with perfectly judged throttle response and real-world range that exceeds EPA estimates, while the cabin impresses with excellent quietness, comfortable air suspension, and tech features like the ambient light bar and reliable wireless charging. However, the $100,000 price tag feels unjustified given material compromises—plastic speaker grilles instead of metal, inconsistent control plastics, and fingerprint-prone piano-black trim—plus severe depreciation that costs buyers $4 per mile, dropping from $95,745 to $56,000. This is an excellent daily driver for those prioritizing performance and comfort over long-term value retention.

Redline Reviews gave the 2024 BMW i5 M60 xDrive a positive 71/100 OctaneScore, praising its impressive performance (92/100) with nearly 600 horsepower, 0-60 in 3.7 seconds, and luxurious cabin technology (91/100) including power-retractable rear window shades and beautiful carbon fiber accents. However, the review flagged significant value concerns (40/100), noting that ventilated seats cost an extra $500, massaging seats cost $1,000, and heated/cooled seats should be standard at this price point, while interior space also falls slightly short of competitors due to platform compromises. The reviewer adored the i5's high-tech, modern interior and conservative luxury design, but the poor feature-to-price ratio is a real drawback. The i5 M60 is best suited for performance-focused luxury buyers who prioritize acceleration and tech over competitive pricing on premium amenities.

SavageGeese's review of the 2024 BMW i5 M60 lands on a mixed assessment with a 42/100 OctaneScore, highlighting compelling performance and comfort but significant drawbacks in value and driving feel. The sedan excels in livability and reliability, offering excellent seats, a quiet cabin thanks to the battery pack, and strong build quality, while its 3.7-second 0-60 time and nimble handling make it genuinely quick for its nearly 5,300-pound weight. However, the nearly $95,000 price tag proves hard to justify given its weak 230-mile real-world range, slow 400-volt charging architecture, polarizing styling, and critically, lifeless steering that provides no feedback despite the car's responsive dynamics. The i5 M60 is best suited for buyers prioritizing luxury sedan comfort and acceleration who can overlook its modest EV efficiency and feel disconnected from their driving experience at a premium price.

Doug DeMuro gave the 2024 BMW i5 a positive 63/100 rating, praising it as an excellent luxury commuter car with standout driving technology, spacious rear seats, and impressive performance—the M60 delivers 590 horsepower with 0-60 in 3.3 seconds, while the reverse camera features color-coded obstacle detection that outperforms Audi's systems. The main drawbacks are bland styling (BMW's large electric grille lacks purpose), limited range at 255-295 miles depending on drivetrain, and a steep starting price around $68,000 that may feel pricey for some buyers. The i5 is ideal for practical luxury buyers seeking a comfortable, high-tech sedan for daily driving, though it will disappoint driving enthusiasts who want more styling personality.

Redline Reviews gives the BMW i5 M60 xDrive a strong positive assessment (79/100 OctaneScore), praising its exceptional performance and design, with the M60 delivering nearly 600 horsepower and 0-60 mph in 3.7 seconds while maintaining a conventionally styled appearance that looks essentially identical to the gas-powered 5 Series. The vehicle excels in livability with a spacious 17 cubic feet of trunk space and cabin technology featuring the latest iDrive 8.5 software, though the review highlights a significant value concern—cooled seats are an inexplicable paid upgrade on a $90,000+ vehicle, and despite strong pricing against competitors like the EQE 580, the overall cost proposition isn't exceptional. The i5 is an excellent choice for luxury sedan buyers seeking performance and technology in a midsize electric package, though budget-conscious shoppers may want to carefully evaluate options given the mounting cost of optional features.