TheStraightPipes gave the 2024 BMW 5 Series i5 M60 xDrive a positive 63/100 OctaneScore, praising its exceptional livability and driving technology—the suspension delivers a feather-like ride over imperfections, while the adaptive cruise control and automatic lane changing work flawlessly at speed. Performance is equally strong, with 593 horsepower, excellent launch control acceleration, and impressive sport boost capability, though TheStraightPipes notes the synthetic engine sound in sport mode and cumbersome driving mode customization feel forced. The design is polarizing with a cool illuminating M grille, but value is a significant concern, with the tested example reaching $136,000 CAD despite capable features. This is a car for buyers who prioritize comfort, advanced driver assistance, and performance over affordability and authentic engine character.

Throttle House gave the 2024 BMW i5 M60 xDrive a mixed 41/100 score, praising its execution as a comfort-focused luxury sedan with an impressive 593-horsepower powertrain that accelerates to 60 mph in 3.5 seconds and delivers an exhilarating V8-like experience. The standout strengths are its livability (78/100) with sophisticated suspension and powered anti-roll bars that provide a wonderful, floaty ride, and its cabin tech (75/100) featuring gaming console entertainment and smooth electric powertrain performance. However, the vehicle stumbles significantly in reliability (0/100) with cheap-feeling door cards, light doors, and subpar vegan leather materials that don't justify its six-figure price tag, while the range of just 280 km in Canadian winters presents practical concerns. This vehicle is best suited for buyers who prioritize highway comfort and luxury over affordability and build quality.