Throttle House gives the 2011 BMW 1M a strong positive rating of 80/100, praising it as an angry, spirited road car that embodies what M division should be. The car excels in value (now approaching six figures in Canada and worth more than an M2), design (with perfect M proportions and distinctive flared arches), and performance (335 horsepower feels quick and perfectly suited to a lightweight platform), plus it features hydraulic steering that delivers genuine feedback unlike newer M cars. The main drawbacks are reliability concerns with the N54 engine (which can suffer charge pipe failures), a driving position that sits too high, and outdated cabin tech lacking modern conveniences like backup cameras. The 1M is for enthusiasts who prioritize character, driving engagement, and investment potential over contemporary creature comforts.