Throttle House gives the 2007 Aston Martin V8 Vantage a decisively positive review (66/100), praising its stunning, timeless design and exceptional performance fundamentals—including a low-mounted naturally aspirated V8, rear-mounted transmission for perfect weight distribution, and hydraulic steering that "blows all modern steering out of the water." The car also delivers surprising livability as a daily driver, feeling like a "big luxurious Miata" that's both quiet and comfortable, with exceptional value at around $50,000 for manual versions. However, the infotainment system is "horrendous" and poorly designed, hand-assembly quality issues can cause interior trim separation, and owners should budget for expensive clutch replacements down the line. This is the car for someone who prioritizes analog driving engagement and timeless beauty over modern conveniences and wants an attainable piece of automotive passion.

Doug DeMuro gives the 2007 Aston Martin V8 Vantage a strong 80/100 rating, praising its exceptional design and outstanding value—he highlights the gorgeous interior dashboard with beautiful stitching, the exotic Swan Wing doors, and the fact that you can purchase this true exotic car for the price of a new small crossover. The car impresses with solid performance from its 4.3L V8 engine and excellent reliability, with DeMuro noting his own ownership of 20,000 miles with no real problems. However, the V8 Vantage falls short on livability with cramped cup holders, no armrest storage, and a tiny sun visor that feels at odds with its luxury positioning. This is the car for someone willing to sacrifice everyday practicality in exchange for affordable exotic sports car thrills and head-turning design.