Doug DeMuro gives the 2005 Acura NSX a decidedly positive review with an OctaneScore of 84/100, praising it as an absolute automotive icon with a perfect analog driving experience. The NSX excels in reliability and driving technology, with DeMuro noting that a 129,000-mile example "looks like any other Japanese car" compared to worn-out Ferraris, while the rev-matching shifter and Xenon headlights earn perfect scores. However, cabin technology and livability present quirks and compromises—including an odd detached key fob with a useless blank button, climate vents on the door panels instead of the dashboard, and embarrassingly inadequate cup holders that the lid closes on. The 2005 NSX is for enthusiasts who prioritize analog driving purity, Japanese reliability, and automotive heritage over modern convenience features.