Verdict
Hyundai Santa Fe and Volkswagen Atlas are dead even on Octane Score at 75, though reviewers don't agree on everything underneath that number. The Hyundai Santa Fe wins the most individual categories, taking 4 of 8 where both have enough coverage to call.
Reviewers
Hyundai Santa Fe
Auto Buyers Guide, Edmunds, Redline Reviews, SavageGeese, TheStraightPipes, Throttle House
Volkswagen Atlas
Auto Buyers Guide, Redline Reviews, SavageGeese