Verdict
The Porsche Macan clearly out-scores the Alfa Romeo Tonale overall, 74 to 66. The Porsche Macan wins the most individual categories, taking 7 of 8 where both have enough coverage to call. The biggest gap is in Reliability, where the Porsche Macan leads by 27 points.
Reviewers
Alfa Romeo Tonale
Auto Buyers Guide, Edmunds, Redline Reviews, SavageGeese, TheStraightPipes
Porsche Macan
Auto Buyers Guide, Doug DeMuro, Edmunds, Redline Reviews, SavageGeese, TheStraightPipes